- REUTERS/Wolfgang Rattay
Brexit just put Japan in an uncomfortable position.
In the immediate market reaction to the Brexit vote, the yen rocketed higher against the dollar and the pound as investors pulled into the safe-haven currency.
The yen has reversed some of its gains over the last few days, but it’s now up about 19% against the dollar for the year, currently hovering around 102.78.
Plus, a CitiFX Strategy team led by Steven Englander argued on Monday that “USDJPY has significant room to drop below 100.”
And this stronger yen environment could create problems for the Japanese government and central bank, both of which have been struggling to jump-start the economy via the ambitious Abenomics plan.
“A stronger currency creates a headwind for the Bank of Japan’s efforts to boost inflation,” Capital Economics’ Chief Asia Economist Mark Williams and Senior Japan Economist Marcel Thieliant said in a note to clients on Monday.
- Capital Economics
“For a start, the sharp strengthening of the exchange rate implies that import prices will continue to fall rapidly in coming months. What’s more, a stronger exchange rate also diminishes the foreign earnings of Japanese firms,” the note said.
In light of this, some analysts now think that the Bank of Japan could ease at its next meeting – or could even try to directly intervene in FX.
“The risk-off environment triggered by the Brexit decision raises the likelihood of a policy response by Japanese authorities,” HSBC economist Izumi Devalier said in a note to clients last Friday.
“We expect the Bank of Japan to respond with additional QE, either at its next scheduled meeting on 29 July or in an earlier emergency board meeting,” the note said. “There is also a greater risk of direct FX intervention by the authorities. But this is unlikely to prevent USDJPY from ending the year below.”
Notably, at an emergency meeting on on Monday, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe told Finance Minister Taro Aso to closely monitor the currency and to take “various, aggressive responses to ensure stability in financial and currency markets.”
“Risks and uncertainty remain in financial markets,” Abe said, according to Reuters. “We need to continue to work toward market stability.”
Still, even if the authorities move to respond to the stronger yen, it may not be enough.
- Capital Economics
“If worries about a deepening crisis in the EU drive another surge of safe haven flows into Japan, even direct foreign exchange intervention would probably not prevent the yen from strengthening,” Thieliant wrote in a note to clients on Wednesday. “The historical track record [for FX intervention] is discouraging.”
Thieliant also shared a chart showing two periods of major FX intervention by Japan. For what it’s worth, the yen kept appreciating in both cases despite foreign currency purchases.
Here’s Thieliant again:
“What eventually stopped the yen from appreciating further in 2012 was the introduction of large-scale monetary easing by the Bank of Japan, as well as its earlier anticipation. … The increase in foreign exchange reserves during intervention episodes was small compared to the surge in the BoJ’s assets following the launch of Quantitative and Qualitative Easing.”
Another extreme possibility that has been floated for Japan has been “helicopter money” – although some are still skeptical that the bank would go for that.
“The very concept of a helicopter drop of money relies crucially on irreversibility of base money,” Credit Suisse research analysts Hiromichi Shirakawa and Takashi Shiono wrote in a note on Wednesday. “The BoJ has made no such commitment to irreversibility of monetary base at this point, meaning that its current easing framework does not fall under the category of ‘helicopter money’. The existence of a +2% inflation target (‘price stability goal’) has clearly made it impossible for the BoJ to commit to the irreversibility.”
The bottom line is that investors’ dive into the yen following the Brexit vote has put Japan into an awkward position – and it’s going to be interesting to see what it does next.