- Business Insider
The US Supreme Court ruled in favor of affirmative action at the University of Texas Austin (UT) last Thursday, further validating the use of race in admissions policies around the country.
After the ruling, the hashtag #BeckyWithTheBadGrades, a modification of the Beyonce song lyric “Becky with the good hair,” began trending on Twitter.
The pop culture reference comes from the album “Lemonade” and refers to the woman with whom Beyonce insinuates her husband, Jay-Z, had an affair.
As Emma Pettit of The Chronicle of Higher Education explains:
“For those not well versed in Beyoncé, on the track she tells an ex-lover that because she is no longer around to put up with his nonsense, “he better call Becky with the good hair.” “Becky” is a term for a stereotypical white woman, and the mention of her “good hair” alludes to society’s elevation of whiteness, especially white beauty, and how whiteness is considered “good” or preferable to any nonwhite alternative. Thus “Becky with the good hair” became a succinct phrase on the internet to call out white privilege.”
The “Becky” persona goes back further than Beyonce though.
Twitter users began comparing “Becky” and Abigail Fisher, the woman at the center of the Fisher v. UT case. Fisher was denied admission to Texas’ flagship public university in 2008 and claimed her race played a factor in her rejection.
Fisher argued that the university denied her admission in favor of less-qualified black and Hispanic students, which, consequently, violated her right to equal protection under the law.
UT has an admissions policy called the Top 10% Plan, which grants automatic acceptance to students within the top 10% of their graduating class into any public university in the state. For the rest of its admissions, UT employs a “holistic” review policy, which includes a number of personal and academic factors, including race. The case scrutinized the holistic elements of UT’s admissions, often used to increase diversity.
The “Becky” tweets center on the assumption that if Fisher’s grades were “good” enough that she fell within the top 10% of her class, she would have automatically been admitted to UT.
Court documents show that her high school grades were below the average for accepted students. She scored an 1180 on the SAT. UT’s website puts the average SAT score at 1274. She also graduated with a 3.59 GPA. On Twitter, users mocked Fisher’s so-called “bad” grades.
“You was lookin for lawyers when you shoulda been looking for tutors.” ???????? #BeckyWithTheBadGrades
— $porty $pice (@DrBlackBarbie_) June 26, 2016
— Wright (@JuWrightTN) June 26, 2016
— Jabria (@cool_Bri225) June 26, 2016
The Supreme Court’s ruling last week brought to a close Fisher’s case which had been argued in different courts since 2012.
Experts watching the case have argued that the outcome could have a far-reaching effect on the ability of universities around the US to consider race in admissions.
At Harvard, for example, an anti-affirmative action group called Students for Fair Admissions filed a complaint against the Ivy League school in 2014, which claims Asian-Americans applicants are held to a higher standard than others and must achieve high tests scores to be accepted.