It’s no secret that Lockheed Martin’s F-35C naval variant has been plagued by cost overruns and setbacks throughout it’s production, but now it seems Boeing, Lockheed’s main rival, smells blood in the water and is capitalizing on the aircraft’s troubles.
The F-35C promised to revolutionize carrier aircraft by becoming the first stealth plane to launch from catapults at sea, but as production lags and costs rise, even President Donald Trump took notice, calling the program “out of control” and ordering a review of the costs and capabilities compared to Boeing’s latest offering.
As Dan Gillian, Boeing’s vice president of F/A-18 and EA-18 programs told Business Insider in January, the defense giant has been working on an update to the F/A-18 for years, and he thinks it could cover a significant portion of the F-35C’s job on cost and on schedule.
Boeing has proposed what it’s calling the F/A-18 Advanced Super Hornet, an update on the carrier aircraft that has served the Navy for decades. Meanwhile, F-35 advocates swear that no matter how you modify an F/A-18, it will still lack one essential ingredient that makes the F-35 so revolutionary – stealth.
- Matt Cardy/Getty Images
While the Advanced Super Hornet would feature conformal fuel tanks to increase its range, or even possibly an enclosed weapons pod to greatly improve stealth, it will never be as stealthy as the F-35, which was designed with stealth in every angle and curve of its fuselage.
But here’s where the war of words starts to unfold: Boeing maintains that the F-35, with all its stealth, must still rely on Boeing’s EA-18, the electronic attack variant of its F/A-18 to beat down enemy radars and signal emitters before the F-35 swoops in.
A senior scientist working on stealth aircraft dispute that point to Business Insider, calling it disinformation. The scientist requested to anonymity due to the sensitive nature of US military capabilities.
While the actual war plan for US carrier-based jets remains classified, and Business Insider has no way of knowing, nor desire in publishing such critical details, it certainly seems that a battle for positioning has taken place at the highest levels of the Pentagon between the two defense giants.
Boeing and Lockheed officials told Business Insider that the US Navy intends to keep both F/A-18s, in some iteration, and F-35 squadrons, flying off carriers into the 2040s.
But according to a report on Defense One, Boeing advocates have even gone as far as shopping around an anonymous white paper detailing the F-35’s shortfalls and the F-18, saying that the Navy’s plan to replace F-18s with F-35s “leaves significant capability gaps against emerging threats” and will leave “the Navy with a significant inventory shortfall.”
The result of Trump’s review of the F-35C, and the Navy’s ultimate decision on what mix of these aircraft to acquire may end up serving as a referendum on the concept of stealth itself.