- REUTERS/Ben Nelms
A new report estimates that legalizing marijuana could generate up to $28 billion in federal, state, and local tax revenue.
That’s about the same as the GDP of the Hermit Kingdom, North Korea.
The report, from nonpartisan research group the Tax Foundation, arrived at the $28 billion figure by combining a $23-per-pound tax – currently set on tobacco at the federal level – with a 10% sales tax on all marijuana products.
The number also includes $7 billion in federal revenue, $5.5 billion from business taxes, and $1.5 billion from income and payroll taxes.
To start, the report found that marijuana is a $45 billion industry in the US alone. This equates to 26 million pounds of marijuana consumed – whether smoked, eaten, or somehow ingested – per year.
And tax collection from Washington and Colorado, where a thriving commercial market for marijuana exists, has exceeded initial estimates.
Colorado anticipated around $70 million of tax revenue from marijuana. But the state will likely pull in $140 million – double the initial estimate – in 2016, according to the report.
The story is similar for Washington. After initial challenges in obtaining the commercial-licensing system online, the Tax Foundation expects the state to pull in over $270 million in taxes by the end of 2016.
The report also warned of some limitations to conducting business for marijuana companies under the current regulatory structure – ones that the marijuana industry will have to meet to “mature” and generate the predicted revenue.
First, profit margins need to reach at least 100% and up to 1,000% for marijuana companies because of the high risk of doing business, including lack of access to institutional banking, legal issues, and imprisonment. That’s a much higher margin than even the tobacco industry.
If marijuana does become legal at the federal level, then the risk for operators would significantly reduce and bring down the returns needed to start marijuana companies. This, in turn, would pave the way for would-be entrepreneurs, according to the Tax Foundation.
- Reuters/Robert Galbraith
Second, if tax rates are set too high, then the increase in price would directly pass to the consumer, according to the report. This could encourage a black market, ultimately undoing the work for legalization and causing a loss in tax revenue.
On top of that, if and when federal legalization happens, the Tax Foundation expects tax revenue to decline a bit initially – from $28 billion to $22 billion.
It’s simple supply-and-demand economics. As the risks involved with entering the industry reduce, more operators will ramp up production. This, in turn, will drive down prices, causing a decrease in sales as well as a decline in profit, which will lead to lower tax revenue overall.
A majority of Americans support legalizing marijuana, according to a CBS poll conducted in April. And a number of states, including California in November, plan to vote on full legalization.