- Netflix posted strong third-quarter earnings and subscriber growth on October 16, but shares tanked more than 36% over the following two months as the broader tech sector came under pressure.
- After bottoming at $231.23 in late December, Netflix shares have surged by more than 45%.
- The company’s recent rebound is overreacted in the eyes of short seller Andrew Left.
- Netflix’s market-capitalization gain over the past 12 days equals 12 DreamWorks Animations, 12 Lionsgates, 10 Rokus, or 5 Hulus, Left said.
- Watch Netflix trade live.
Netflix investors have too much confidence in the stock and lack adequate judgment, the short-seller Andrew Left’s Citron Research said Friday.
“NFLX investors at this level as blind as Bird Box,” Citron Research wrote in a tweet. The firm said shares would fall back to the $300 level – more than 10% below Netflix’s Friday closing price. Bird Box is a Netflix movie that stars Sandra Bullock as a mother who’s trying to protect her children after a supernatural force that kills you if you see it wipes out most of humanity.
Shares of the video-streaming giant have been on a roller-coaster ride in recent months.
On October 16, the company posted strong third-quarter earnings and subscriber growth, but shares tanked more than 36% over the following two months as the broader tech sector came under pressure. At the time, Bernstein analyst Todd Juenger linked the rising interest-rate environment, which tends to penalize companies, like Netflix, that are short of cash.
After bottoming at $231.23 on December 24, Netflix shares have rebounded by more than 40%. The gains have come after the Federal Reserve said its future rate hikes were not on a preset course.
The stock’s recent rally is too much, in the eyes of Left. Netflix’s market capitalization has soared by $45 billion over the past 12 days, the equivalent of 12 DreamWorks Animations, 12 Lionsgates, 10 Rokus, or 5 Hulus, Citron said.
But Wall Street is bullish on the tech giant.
“After six months of stock underperformance & key debates emerging about competition, margins & [free cash flow], we think these debates are better understood by investors and reflected in the current stock price,” UBS analysts said on Thursday. The bank has a “neutral” rating and $400 price target.
Netflix was up 56% in the past twelve months.
Travis Clark contributed to this story.
- Netflix analysts answer critical questions about the streaming giant and the future of the industry (NFLX)
- ‘Long-term fundamental trends remain very, very, very much intact’: Here’s what Wall Street is saying about Netflix’s record subscriber growth
- Markets Insider