- Samantha Lee/Business Insider
Founded by entrepreneur Elon Musk in 2002, SpaceX did not have an easy start – it was bordering on bankruptcy in 2008 after three failed launches.
Its success has so far relied on its workhorse launcher: the 229-foot-tall Falcon 9 rocket. But continued industry dominance is anything but guaranteed.
In the near future, Musk and SpaceX will face competition from a number of companies, including Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin and Paul Allen’s Stratolaunch Systems, that are developing reusable, next-generation rocket engines, boosters, and spaceships.
Here’s how the competition in the new space race stacks up.
This story was updated with new information. It was originally published at 10:20 a.m. ET on March 4, 2018.
United Launch Alliance
- United Launch Alliance
Aerospace industry titans Boeing and Lockheed Martin formed ULA in 2005, and the company currently relies on its Delta IV Heavy launcher to get the biggest payloads into space. But that rocket costs at least $350 million per launch – several times more expensive than SpaceX’s new and reusable $90 million Falcon Heavy system. Plus, Delta IV Heavy can only lift half as much payload as the Falcon Heavy.
As an answer to SpaceX’s new rocket, ULA is working on a more powerful and partly reusable launcher called Vulcan. That rocket will recycle the engines of its booster, which is the biggest and most costly part of a rocket. (And the engines make up about two-thirds of a booster’s cost.)
According to ULA’s plan, a system called SMART will pop the engines off, guide them through Earth’s atmosphere behind an aeroshell, and parachute them toward the ground. A helicopter will then grab the parachute and engines.
A forthcoming system called ACES will also make the upper stage of the rocket reusable and refuel-able in orbit.
Tory Bruno, ULA’s CEO, told Business Insider that a Vulcan launch will cost below $100 million to start.
One of SpaceX’s lowest-cost and biggest competitors is ArianeGroup, which is often known by its launch-focused subsidiary, Arianespace.
The company is working on a follow-up to its highly successful Ariane 5 rocket, dubbed Ariane 6. It may launch as soon as 2020. The most powerful variant of Ariane 6 could potentially carry about twice as much payload as SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rocket into orbit some 22,236 miles above Earth.
At first, Ariane 6 won’t have reusable engines. But SpaceNews reports that the rockets may eventually get equipped with reusable Prometheus engines – expensive parts that a winged, pop-off machine called Adeline might fly back to a runway.
In the end, Ariane 6’s makers expect the rocket to achieve lower ounce-for-ounce launch prices that what SpaceX currently offers.
- Blue Origin
One of SpaceX’s biggest looming rivals is also the most secretive.
Founded by Amazon billionaire Jeff Bezos in 2000, Blue Origin has been most public about its smaller space tourism rocket system, New Shepard. But in September 2016, Blue Origin announced its plans for the enormous, reusable, and orbit-capable New Glenn rocket system.
Reusable rocket engines, called BE-4s, will power that launcher. Its biggest future iteration will stand about 313 feet tall, have three rocket stages, and possibly make voyages to the moon or Mars routine.
Bezos is planning to debut the first New Glenn rocket in 2020. Blue Origin has begun that work in a 750,000-square-foot hangar in Cape Canaveral, Florida (Business Insider asked to visit, but the company declined).
It’s not certain how much a New Glenn launch will cost, though the booster will take off and land like SpaceX’s, allowing it to get reused for future launches. That would save Blue Origin tens of millions of dollars in the process.
As of March 2017, Blue Origin had at least one customer signed up to launch a payload.
- Virgin Orbit
SpaceX is focused on launching large satellites, but Sir Richard Branson of Virgin-brand fame is aiming to corner the market on sending lighter payloads into orbit.
Branson’s newest company, Virgin Orbit, uses a large airplane (“Cosmic Girl) to efficiently lift a rocket (“LauncherOne”) high in the sky. Once at maximum altitude, the airplane drops the rocket, which then throttles a payload toward low-Earth orbit (LEO) some 250 miles above the planet.
For $12-$15 million, Virgin Orbit can rocket payloads weighing up to 1,100 lbs to LEO. That’s small compared to the 140,000-lb payload capacity of SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy. But for many customers that want to launch small satellites – the Department of Defense included – half a ton is plenty.
Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen used his wealth to form an ambitious air-to-launch company in 2011.
Called Stratolaunch, the launch system will dwarf Branson’s Virgin Orbit scheme. Allen had his company build the largest aircraft in the world, which engineers made by cannibalizing two 747-400 jet airplanes.
The carrier aircraft has a 385-foot wingspan, and it will tow a launcher to high altitude, drop it, and fire it toward space.
The carrier is capable of lifting an object that weighs up of 500,000 lbs. That’s more than enough to send a rocket or spaceship with a crew of two or three people into orbit.
In fact, Allen’s team is contemplating making a new space plane called “Black Ice,” which would be about as big as one of NASA’s former space shuttles.
“You make your rocket a plane,” Jean Floyd, the CEO of Stratolaunch System, told Christian Davenport for his new book, “The Space Barons: Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and the Quest to Colonize the Cosmos.”
“So, you have an airplane carrying a plane that’s fully reusable,” Floyd added. “You don’t throw anything away ever. Only fuel.”
The People’s Republic of China is powering ahead in its fast-paced spaceflight program.
Although Chinese officials have remarked that they can’t match SpaceX’s reusable-rocket-launch pricing, that may not be true in the future. The nation is reportedly (and secretly) working to build a reusable, hypersonic space plane.
They plan launch it for the first time in 2025, and might later launch a fully reusable and capable nuclear-powered model.
The billionaire Robert Bigelow, who is working to build inflatable space stations, is worried about China’s growing prowess in space.
“They’re offering very attractive terms and conditions and features that the commercial sector is going to have a horrible time trying to compete with,” Bigelow said during a recent press briefing.
Testing for NASA’s gigantic Space Launch System rocket is moving along. When the dust settles many years from now, it may tower above and outdo all other rockets ever built, at least in terms of power and lift capability.
But on cost, it won’t ever compare. NASA has already spent about $23 billion on the project, and will need more than $210 billion in funding to reach Mars with the launcher, according to the Office of Inspector General. And that’s not even to set foot on the planet’s surface – just orbit it. (Though the first Mars astronauts might explore the moon Phobos.)
NASA is projected to launch the first SLS rocket in 2020 at the earliest.
- Orbital ATK
Orbital ATK is one of the companies working on the booster for SLS, but the aerospace and defense company has a big side project: the Next Generation Launch system, or NGL.
NGL is designed to compete for heavy-lift payloads, including military spy satellites. The first NGL launch is slated for 2024, and a souped-up “heavy” configuration may put about half as much payload into orbit as a Falcon Heavy.
NGL is partly a resurrection of Ares I: a launcher the company was building for NASA until the program lost its funding. Like Ares I, NGL will use solid rocket boosters similar to the space shuttle’s.
Such boosters can be reused after intense refurbishment work, but Orbital ATK told Space.com in 2017 that – at least for now – it doesn’t plan to reuse any parts of NGL. Instead, the company aims to keep the launcher’s price low and reliability high “by integrating common elements, such as avionics, flight computers and materials for composite structures” across all of its other rockets.
The company did not provide estimated launch pricing to Business Insider in time for publication.
What’s next for SpaceX
Now that its Falcon Heavy rocket is proven to work, SpaceX is shifting a lot of resources toward its most ambitious project: the Big Falcon Rocket (also called the Big F–king Rocket).
The 348-foot-tall, fully reusable system is scheduled for an “aspirational” first launch toward Mars in 2022. Its enormous spaceship – which sits atop a similarly enormous booster – is slated to roll out of SpaceX’s facilities in Texas and begin hopping around with short test launches sometime in 2019.
But a series of remarks made in September 2017, Musk said the BFR will come to replace everything SpaceX has built thus far, since its total reusability means it won’t cost much to launch payloads of any size – primarily just the price of fuel.
“We want to have one system, one booster and ship, that replaces Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, and Dragon,” Musk said of SpaceX’s other rockets. “If we can do that, then all the resources that are used for Falcon 9, Heavy, and Dragon can be applied to this system.”
In a way, SpaceX is currently competing with itself by advancing the BFR. But if the company can really create a fully reusable launcher that’s the largest and most powerful in the world, it could change the course of human history – and push it toward the stars.