President-elect Donald Trump made one of the first hires of his administration on Sunday by selecting his campaign CEO, Steve Bannon, to serve as White House chief strategist.
The appointment of the 62-year-old former executive chairman of Breitbart News set off a firestorm of criticism, as politicians of all political stripes argued that he harbored sympathies for white nationalist arguments and rhetoric.
Organizations including the Southern Poverty Law Center and the Anti-Defamation League condemned Bannon for “aggressively pushing stories against immigrants” and his association with “unabashed anti-Semites and racists.”
The characterization of Bannon himself as anti-Semitic, racist, and white nationalist has been based mostly on articles published at Brietbart News, an alt-right news website.
But, while it does not stretch the imagination to hold Bannon accountable for material published at the organization under his leadership, it seems prudent to examine Bannon’s own words and writings to try to understand his worldview.
Much can be gleaned from Bannon’s numerous columns at Breitbart since taking over in 2012, as well his speeches at conferences and on radio shows.
His Breitbart columns
- Breitbart News
Broadly speaking, Bannon’s columns at Breitbart reflect abhorrence for so-called mainstream media organizations, such as The New York Times and CNN, and “the Left.”
He criticized Bloomberg View as a “billionaire-funded game preserve of old liberal pundits,” asserted that the “left end of the MSM disdains this country,” and derided journalistic luminaries such as Walter Cronkite, Edward R. Murrow, Sam Donaldson, and Dan Rather as “partisan egoists.”
Bannon referred to liberals as “Koolaid drinkers” and called members of the Black Lives Matter movement and New Black Panthers “the crazies.”
He frequently invoked George Soros as a liberal bogeyman, describing him as one of Hillary Clinton’s “billionaire financiers.”
In a column from July, Bannon accused The Times and the mainstream media of engaging in “Newspeak” and “Doublethink,” terms birthed by George Orwell for his dystopian novel “Nineteen Eighty-Four” to describe language used to limit freedom of thought and propagate political indoctrination.
Bannon referred to the “dirty work” being done by the “MSM,” or mainstream media, in a January 2014 column critical of The Times for a book review of “The Loudest Voice in the Room,” a biography of Fox News founder Roger Ailes. In a 2013 column he wrote about “billionaire-liberal media patrons” and the “billionaire-funded game of liberal-left advocacy organizations” to smear conservative media.
The only member of the so-called MSM to not receive outright scorn is Fox News, which he describes as “a lonely fair-and-balanced bastion” and a “centrist” news organization.
In an August column, not long after Ailes’ ouster from Fox News amid multiple sexual-harassment allegations, Bannon criticized the news channel and the “Minor Murdochs” whom he sees as in charge of the news organization. He criticized James and Lachlan Murdoch, the sons of Rupert Murdoch, the chairman of Fox News’ parent company News Corp., as being in favor of “politically correct liberalism” and being a “progressive green,” with an interest in global warming. To Bannon, not even Fox News can be trusted anymore:
“In addition, as everyone knows, Fox’s secret sauce has been ‘fair and balanced’ – it was the one TV channel that right-of-center Americans trusted.”
“Yet nothing is permanent. As they say in sports, You’re only as good as your last game. And so, too, in TV: You’re only as good as your last show.”
Bannon’s most pointed criticism of Fox News has revolved around host Megyn Kelly, whom Bannon characterized in columns as being an opportunist using Fox News as a launchpad. He skewered Kelly for asking questions during the first Republican presidential debate in 2015 in “the language of the left” and called her performance “attention-grabbing of the highest order.”
Bannon frequently employed a rhetorical strategy that framed an issue – or even two unrelated issues – as an either/or choice.
In response to the Dallas police shooting in July, and amid questions about police violence, Bannon posed a “mega-question for 2016”: Should Americans let “street hoodlums” or “duly appointed authorities” run the country? Similarly, he asked whether police should be “reprogrammed to look the other way” from criminals or be “tough-but-fair” and enforce the law.
In his mind, that is the choice Black Lives Matter “crazies” have forced on the country.
The Human Dignity Institute talk and Breitbart podcasts
- Kirk Irwin/Getty Images for SiriusXM
Bannon has also revealed his views while delivering speeches and hosting Breitbart News Daily, a radio show on SiriusXM’s conservative news channel Patriot.
In the summer of 2014, Bannon gave a speech and answered questions at the Human Dignity Institute, a conservative religious group that was holding a conference at the Vatican. BuzzFeed attended the meeting and published an invaluable transcript of Bannon’s remarks on Tuesday.
A dominant theme in the talk, and on Breitbart News Daily, was his belief that the West was engaged in “a global war against Islamic fascism.”
“We have to face a very unpleasant fact: and that unpleasant fact is that there is a major war brewing, a war that’s already global. It’s going global in scale, and today’s technology, today’s media, today’s access to weapons of mass destruction it’s going to lead to a global conflict that I believe has to be confronted today,” Bannon said at the Human Dignity Institute.
In December 2015, Bannon interviewed Trump for Breitbart News Daily. In the interview, he appeared to frame solving the problems posed by climate change and ISIS as mutually exclusive.
“Do you agree with the pope and President Obama that [climate change] is absolutely a path to global suicide, if specific deals are not cut in Paris, versus focusing on radical Islam?” Bannon asked Trump, who chose ISIS.
Bannon appears to believe the secularization of the US is tied to the rise of “jihadist Islamic fascism,” which he has said is “metastasizing far quicker than governments can handle it” and is headed toward the UK and the rest of Europe.
Bannon described three converging forces – the rise of “jihadist Islamic fascism,” “state-sponsored capitalism,” and what he called the “Ayn Rand or the Objectivist School of libertarian capitalism.” He asked those in attendance at his Human Dignity Institute speech to ask whether the US should put “a cap on wealth creation and distribution.” Moreover, he frequently asserted that the “Judeo-Christian West” was at its most prosperous when capitalists were strong believers in those faiths.
Bannon spent much of the HDI talk criticizing aspects of capitalism, particularly what he called “crony capitalism” and “corporatism,” which he asserted had overtaken the US and Europe. He repeatedly trashed bankers for the 2008 financial crisis and the US government for bailing out the banks and creating “a free option” for the financial industry to gamble.
His deepest scorn was reserved for “the Republican establishment,” which he described as “a collection of crony capitalists that feel that they have a different set of rules of how they’re going to comport themselves.”
Here’s how Bannon describes the tea party and Breitbart’s dominant theme:
“And the theme is middle-class and working-class people – they’re saying, ‘Hey, I’m working harder than I’ve ever worked. I’m getting less benefits than I’m ever getting through this, I’m incurring less wealth myself, and I’m seeing a system of fat cats who say they’re conservative and say they back capitalist principles, but all they’re doing is binding with corporatists.’ Right? Corporatists, to garner all the benefits for themselves.”
When a questioner at the event asked Bannon about charges of anti-Semitism or “racial” aspects of movements like the tea party, Bannon acknowledged that those “elements” and “fringe organizations” show up, but he asserted that they would “burn away over time” as the movement becomes more mainstream.
“I think when you look at any kind of revolution – and this is a revolution – you always have some groups that are disparate,” he said. “I think that will all burn away over time and you’ll see more of a mainstream center-right populist movement.”
Bannon didn’t touch on immigration during his talk, but in a November podcast with Trump, he said he was to the right of Trump on US immigration laws. When Trump said he wanted to let foreign students who graduate from US colleges stay in the US, Bannon disagreed. Earlier in the conversation, he criticized Silicon Valley for having numerous CEOs from Asia.